The Fates of the GTA Protagonists (1984-2008*)

There’s a reason for the asterisk

This would’ve been about the GTA protagonists from just the 3D games, but it’s been long enough at 18 years that leaving Niko, Johnny, and Luis alone is how I get my head bitten off by Trevor Phillips.

I’m half-joking… he’s capable of worse. Manhunt 2 said no to his audition because he’s too professional.

The criteria is starting from 1984 to 2008 to match the chronological order and before I continue, other candidates fit on account of the 3D universe of GTA games overlapping with that of the Manhunt games. I’ve only played Manhunt 1 to completion. Manhunt 2 is still going deliciously bloody well…

https://manhuntgame.fandom.com/wiki/Shovel

Normally, I wouldn’t hide content behind a filter, but Manhunt is notoriously graphic. The uncensored and more gruesome versions deserve their own post. ~(>_<。)\

But violent kills and the wider 3D Rockstar universe aren’t the focus of this post, though it does make up a majority. This is going to be filled with a hell of a lotta conjecture. By my count, only two characters are confirmed dead, the others aren’t but have no other references or confirmed anything beyond their latest chronological appearances.

I’m also starting with GTA: Vice City Stories and ending with The Ballad of Gay Tony. Why? For much of the same reasons I play God of War’s Greek Saga starting at Ascension and ending at III. Who gives a f[grunt]k about technological prowess? I’m here to see Kratos’s character from remorseful weapon to vengeful dark messiah! ಠ╭╮ಠ. Definitive information on characters’ precise birthdates is hard to come by. Even something as vague as a year doesn’t tell me much and a lot of the info I can glean comes from forums, archived or otherwise, and the four trillion wiki sites that only nine people use every hour on the hour. For that reason, when I list a characters’ birthdate, if nothing is confirmed or even agreed upon by most gamers, then my fallback is the voice actor’s birthday or the game’s original release date if I don’t know the voice actor’s birthday, so eventual ports to a console from the same generation won’t count since not every PS2 release matched the Xbox and vice versa. Sony and Microsoft have different hardware.

So starting with the man who least wanted to be where he was and simply couldn’t ask for a better and more competent brother: Victor “Vic” Vance.

Rockstar loves to keep time in a bottle. Jim Croce did it yonks ago and they never learned how to free it because their approach to timelines couldn’t be anymore f[gun cocking]ked if it was paid for. A source claims Vic was born in 1956, with another one suggesting May 11, 1956. This puts him at 28 whenever the hell VCS takes place. 1984? You know what else happens in 1984?

How does this relate to America, Tiberius? ╰( ̄ω ̄o) It doesn’t.

Anyway, Vic defeats his enemies in Sgt. Jerry Martinez, who severely dishonors the uniform more than Vic ever did. Vic is the lesser of two evils, but he probably could’ve reported it to his chain of command. But Martinez had to have been found out anyway by the DoD and in Reagan’s America, he’s really handicapping himself before anyone in his leadership ever does.

There’s no mystery to Vic’s ultimate fate as his death in April 1986 gives way to the next guy on our list. Whichever birthdate is more accurate, Vic Vance was around 29-30 when he was killed by Ricardo Diaz’s men. That being said, Vic had a ton of opportunities to jump ship with just the winnings from not having killed Martinez. The woman he was sheltering perished in the middle because she was waiting by the phone. Even if he did cut out the middlemen Mendez brothers (and Lance (╯▔皿▔)╯), the post-Army life he had was about as stable as Phil Cassidy’s boomshine, and Vic didn’t touch the stuff aside from a very maligned mission. As for the next guy:

For a guy who was under pressure to get Sonny’s money back, the pressure isn’t really felt. It’s not like Vincenzo Cilli in 1998 where the stronzo puts chains on Toni and sets him up every chance he gets. But I’m jumping a couple of wise guy guns all at once there.

Was Sonny really that arrogant? That’s a s[‘ey!]t-load of arrogance, all things considered. If Rockstar ever claimed he was based on a specific mafioso, then I could buy it, but very few lived to be old as dirt or let disease take care of them if their rivals couldn’t. Not everyone could’ve been this guy:

But at least Tommy had a better chance of getting the girl. He didn’t even have to leave her waiting by the phone and he had Colonel Cortez’s blessing. The military dictator of not-Panama gave a mafioso his bless–actually, that’s not really a surprise, it’s not unheard of for the powers that be in the government to rub elbows with the powers that be responsible for leaving blunts under my pillow like my fairy god drug dealer.

Obviously, Tommy lives to the end and is there in the GTA San Andreas introduction for his people to wave off Ken Rosenberg who’s now bald, disbarred, and dancing between rehab and criminal relapse in 1992. At best, Ray Machowski’s relocation to Miami in 2001 (later Vice City since Rockstar saw how successful GTA III was, go figure) can be argued in the Mental Olympics as a hint that Tommy plausibly lived to be over 50 years old. Most accounts claim he was born in 1951, he was 18 by 1969 during the draft and was involved in the Harwood butcher incident of 1971, getting 15 years.

An easy assumption to make is to tie Tommy to his portrayer, the late Ray Liotta, and I was gonna do the same. But on reflection, it’d be the same as mapping CJ to Young Maylay or Samurai Jack to Phil Lamarr. You’re not wrong if you do, but try not to. I will say though that the birthyear holds up for him, though he ages fairly better than most men his age, even if you could still smoke on airlines in the 1980s.

He’s essentially locked to the 3D Universe potentially living past 2007 when Manhunt 2 takes place and if Cottonmouth–the setting for Manhunt 2–is in Georgia, Louisiana, or South Carolina (probably the Georgia coastline), then Tommy’s network from 1986 Florida probably has in-roads there after 21+ years. If he had a successor to carry on his estate, then the Vercetti Gang has nothing to fear, though unlike CJ, his and Vic’s estates consolidated power in one city. CJ builds outward in three across two states.

Modifying CJ’s attributes in an RPG-wards move was a fantastic thing for him.

A stake in a casino in Venturas, a deal with the rapper Madd Dogg, a garage in San Fierro and to the outside world, most people have an inkling or suspect the dirty money going into all of it; CJ is practically the drug dealer on speed dial Nickelback sang about in 2005. Starting from the bottom in LS in 1992, and some can argue Sweet’s too narrow-minded to rise above the bottom and remain a crab in a bucket.

Channel: Tactical Bacon Productions

To be fair, this isn’t really unheard of in specific communities. If you’ve ever watched The Boondocks, you may be primed to believe this is a prominent and persistent generational issue in the black community in America, but looking beyond that, these issues persist in roughly every community. N-gga moments, n-gga synthesis; replace n-gga with some other slur and congratulations, you’ve discovered infighting and ignorance. It needs a better term since it applies to a wider group of people.

Channel: R1CAN1

¯\_(ツ)_/¯, no one’ll call me a sociologist.

Still, Vic may have been poised to build a network that Lance didn’t really inherit by 1986 (Vic being a disgraced Army corporal (which is its own disgrace, all the responsibility, none of the pay boost 〒▽〒) should have the managerial expertise to keep what he gained, but whatever), Tommy and CJ were better at building and keeping their enterprises under their control by the end, though CJ faced more recurring threats than Tommy did and perhaps due to the nature of VCS, Vic’s efforts were even tougher than imagined. So Vic loses his wealth along with his life which Diaz may have stolen after getting him killed, Tommy and Lance both did unto Diaz what he had done unto Vic only for Lance to try the same and die in the process, and if I wanna be fair to Sweet, he at least clarified that he only wanted CJ to repay his debts to his ‘hood. Doesn’t excuse his bulls[yo!]t behavior towards CJ after Toreno sets him free, ungrateful prick.

By the late game, CJ had been running all over the gaff eliminating informants, witnesses, investigators and the like for Tenpenny (without pay) that the end result that Tenpenny was acquitted of all charges hardly comes as a surprise to everyone paying attention. Things calm down after Tenpenny gets the poetic justice he’d been setting up, although CJ’s enterprise was less paranoid than Big Smoke’s by the end. Smoke used to prance about, making connections, and talking to people… a fair amount of which became the bodyguards to his mansion by the end of the game. Then by the end, he didn’t even leave the crack den. He sat there hoarding his money, smoking, playing video games all the time while everyone else did the leg work. Smoke, the Loco Syndicate heads, Ryder (kinda), Tenpenny, B-Dup; just about every one of these guys were suspicious of each other.

Like Stinkmeaner, Crabmiser, Gripenasty, and Pisedofferson. These f[nyukkah]kers hated each other, but always turned their hatred outward. Without hapless fools run into on the daily, it would’ve become a pecking order, and that’s likely what would’ve happened if CJ failed. But after 1992, not much can be said of CJ’s enterprise. By 2013, GTA V’s timeframe, we know that the Grove had turned over to the Ballas, but if I had to wager how that came to pass, the logical conclusion would be that CJ made like a bunch of the OGs over the years and retired to the hills with a family or something. I always read him as mid-20s by 1992. If he was born in 1967 or so, then he’d have the wealth and the means to get out before he’s 40 or so.

Whoever he picked as his successor either ruined the Grove or had a worse judge of character than CJ and they or their successor lost out to the Ballas between 1992 and 2013. Why connect the 3D-verse to the HD-verse? Because San Andreas before GTA V was set in 1992 and it’s the only frame of reference we have outside of snide references in GTA IV.

Then there’s the two Liberty City protagonists who don’t really build any enterprises outward beyond their narrow scopes. Toni Cipriani and Claude.

Starting with Toni in 1998, he was in hiding for four years for whacking a made man. He’s definitely loyal to the Leones and Sal and isn’t the type to tolerate schemes from Vincenzo or McCaffrey. Sadly, this narrow-headed loyalty doesn’t serve him very well as even after he and Sal save the mayor and push the Sicilian Mob outta Liberty, Toni’s compensation is halved. But him being a capo by 2001 and back living with Ma Cipriani fluffs his frame out considerably over the next three years–and he was only 30 in 1998.

Claude may not have given a damn whether Ma was being truthful or just being hard on her boy, but Toni spent a considerable amount of time trying to prove he was a tough guy to just her when Sal could see him risk his neck in real time. Still, his silhouette maximizes at the expense of his intimidation factor, though being a capo still means something even if the feds had been capping the Mafia at every turn.

By GTA III, Claude had been tasked by Asuka into assassinating Salvatore in 2001 and Sal never definitively named any successors or had a clear underboss or consigliere to take over in case he died or went to prison. His son? Nah, Joey was a gearhead. He’d rather fix cars for the mob or whoever would pay than take over and run the mob. Luigi? Not him either, someone had to run the Sex Club 7 and it was better he run it than that fat f[punch]k JD O’Toole. He was already dead by then though, Mickey Hamfists is more of a less intelligent version of Claude, just has a voice this time, and he’s the same guy who has Toni drive him to his house after whacking JD… when they could’ve ditched the car at the crusher first then drive him home.

Dumbass muscle

The only logical successor to Salvatore that I can think of would be Toni as he’s been in this since sometime before 1994 and there’s evidence from Ma that Pa Cipriani himself was a tough guy though I’m not sure if that means he was a wise guy. Whatever the case, Toni’s the best candidate that comes to mind. Rockstar has a horrible habit of introducing plot points and snipping them off unnecessarily. So if Toni becomes Don Antonio Cipriani of the remainder of the Leone Family, why are they still hostile to Claude following Sal’s assassination? I really wanna say there’s a big civil war over those who accepted Toni and those who didn’t since Sal would be paranoid enough to leave the blanks unfilled like a half-finished Mad Lib, but I don’t have any evidence in favor of or against. All I’ve got is pattern recognition, but patterns don’t always point to the same thing. Sometimes people are weird.

ヾ(•ω•`)o こんにちは!

And the 3D GTA universe closes with the biggest weirdo of all:

Vic built and died, Tommy built and lived, CJ built and lived to see it connect in three cities, Toni presumably moved up while Claude helped to move everything down and Claude only moved up because it was the only direction that Catalina was moving. CJ couldn’t match her mental aptitude for violence beat-for-beat because he still had something tangible to return to at the end. Claude was similar in that he had nothing to lose, everything to gain and a single target to work toward, never mind all the people he had to step on to get there.

Now, not every single person had treated him the same way. Asuka was his foot in the door in the Yakuza, but Kenji needed to see him honor himself by busting out a kanbu who reported the success upwards. This association with the Yakuza does a better job of answering why the mob is still on his ass after Sal’s death as the Yakuza would see the Italians as a potential enemy as opposed to the real enemy the Mafia has with the Triads, but it also exposes Claude to their conflicts with the Yardies who also have it out for him after King Courtney double-crosses him to Catalina.

He doesn’t command the same kind of respect as a “Little” Jacob Hughes.

There’s also the Cartel whom Claude was always in trouble with and the Purple Nines, but they’re more of a side to the main course. The Red Jacks and the Yakuza are Claude’s last bit of protection, more so the Yakuza with all the crooked agents they have in their pocket and those same crooked agents can turn a blind eye to their crimes for a cut while also making Claude’s life hell once they figure out the truth behind the assassination of Kenji Kasen. Whoever succeeds as Oyabun/Kumicho and/or Waka-gashira can turn the guns on Claude and force him out of Liberty. Just add to the list of enemies he already has.

The base versions of GTA III leave Cedar Grove blocked off, but the existence of a landlocked GTA put modders and programmers to work crafting the Upstate Liberty mod. This makes it all the more plausible that Claude can slip out of the city and hide in Ghostburg where the opening heist takes place or to a farm in any of the upstate towns. Basically, if you map 3D Liberty onto real-life New York and add the counties north of Westchester and Rockland, then Claude probably escaped and was last seen c. mid-November to early December 2001. That gives Liberty City a second missing person’s case next to Donald Love.

Fun fact about that mod: a closed off tunnel in Ghostburg connects to Carcer City which gives Claude another place to disappear to… Still speculation, this isn’t written in stone. I can and perhaps will connect this all to Manhunt, but I’m not done with Manhunt 2 as of writing so I’m gonna hold off on that until the Christmas write-up and Cash and Lamb can join us for a very bloody Christmas.

Now for a new universe and the new protagonists: Niko Bellic, Johnny Klebitz, and Luis Lopez.

Niko was first so he gets his assessment first. After killing Dimitri or getting screwed over by Dimitri for the last time and getting the worst possible consequences for it by either widowing his cousin-in-law or dropping the last surviving McReary family members to Patrick and Gerald, Niko’s end can be remarkably mundane. Like Claude, he’s not primed to spearhead any new developments and uses his connections to get to the man who betrayed him in Yugoslavia in 1998. Unlike Claude, the massive traitor is no mastermind; he’s merely a junkie chasing a high, short-term satisfaction, and long-term pain. The Darko Brevic that lived in his head didn’t match the Darko Brevic that was probably sleeping under a damn newspaper getting hypothermia on the streets in Bucharest.

Be that as it may, the loose ends are tied and Niko has a clear pathway to what he’d been doing when he first stepped off the boat: driving a taxi around an absurdly decadent city. Not as decadent as what GTA V would evolve into, but LC is getting there.

And why wouldn’t Niko live out the rest of his life as a tired old cabbie? It’s a job anyone can do for a couple of extra dollars and assuming the city is also subject to the real-life congestion pricing tolls that make it hell to drive in the city, then cab drivers need that money. I don’t mean the yellow taxis or the lesser known green taxis with a limited tireprint compared to their more famous counterparts. Private cab drivers who hang around commercial spots citywide. I can’t reliably math it out on the spot, but the Taxi and Limousine Commission of NYC claims passengers pay less for the yellow cabs. I’m fairly certain these guys stay out of the rougher parts of the Bronx, but I’m neither a sociologist nor an economist so I can’t say with certainty if that’s true, I’m only working off my own memories here.

Johnny Klebitz has a definitive end underneath Trevor’s boots, but the handling of his death and his ultimate final moments is something that a lot of people considered disrespectful to Johnny. Many can and have argued that the Lost MC was turned into a shell of what they used to be. They didn’t even have the same footprint as the Angels of Death and I’ll go out on a limb and say letting them come back to be the antagonists for Trevor makes more sense for the times they show up, which honestly isn’t a lot, but they can still be seen in select parts of LS and Blaine County.

They already do this in Chinatown Wars and they’re not friendly there either. Larger footprint, white supremacist foundation contrasted with Johnny’s Jewish upbringing and Huang Lee being a Hong Kong immigrant, a much larger network for Trevor to harass and with Merryweather eventually getting the greenlight to operate on American soil, it follows a larger pattern of harassment from the angriest Canadian since James “The Wolverine” Howlett.

Just sayin’ ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

As for Luis Lopez, the final protagonist to examine, he technically comes back to building up and out. Co-owning and managing the Maisonette 9 and Hercules nightclubs with Gay Tony Prince, Tony coming to LS in 2018 or so to show the protagonist the nightlife could potentially give him a relevancy he hasn’t had in over a decade and one of the healthier outcomes after dislodging the Russian Mob and Ancelotti Family threat from the clubs so that there needn’t be any worry over who’s keeping the lights on.

For Luis, he could be the one continuously making sure those lights stay on at both clubs while Tony’s in San Andreas expanding his footprint, though that doesn’t mean he transferred ownership from himself to Luis. There’s tons of businesspeople in real life who already don’t do that as they don’t have the time or opportunity or prickishness to micromanage every aspect of the life. Try doing that if you own property in five different companies, even if you could, time zones won’t let you.

But assuming Luis keeps the ship from running aground in LC, he could presumably have ‘Rique and ‘Mando join him and keep the wrong crowd out of the clubs and also get some of the celebs who frequent the clubs regularly. They already do that during the drug dealing missions and side-missions, so why not use that experience for something more positive and lucrative? And seeing celebs in Lower Manhattan is pretty much guaranteed; a friend of mine used to work as a barista in college and MTV executives and producers went there a lot. Work where the rich people are and soon enough you’ll get some of your own.

Like they can’t spit game with their boy in the clubs? Though they gotta watch out, these celebs know people >_>.

Vic Vance, Tommy Vercetti, CJ, Toni Cipriani, Claude, Niko Bellic, Johnny Klebitz, and Luis Lopez. Out of eight protagonists, two were killed a few years later; the ones between 1984 and ’92 built expansive networks; two stay loyal to bosses who cultivate bedfellows without the forethought to do some soul searching first, despite the assets to do that beforehand; and two forego cultivation of cash to personally drive bullets into the skulls of those who wronged them. One track minds for Claude and Niko, all things considered, though Claude’s the only one with every reason to do so.

At least these all make sense to me, a lot of these guys are proof that this life isn’t guaranteed for everyone. Even as a satire, there’s a lot of overlap between the GTA games and the Mafia games. You could pursue the life and get the fast money, but also suffer from fast consequences.

Screenshot taken from: Willzyyy – Mafia 2: Chapter #14 – Stairway to Heaven (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SPuKR08sIYE), posted February 4, 2015

Fear, paranoia, the blood of your friends… whatever the rate of this is across the board, the lucky few are the lucky few for a reason. Niko may not have gotten the dream, but the fate he gets is the more enviable of all his enemies on the whole.

Leave a Reply